Anonymous

Ice milk, anyone?

Blue Bell ice cream used to be at least average, if not sometimes pretty tasty. We picked up some rocky road a few weeks ago and it's some nasty stuff. There is NO creaminess -- the taste and texture are that of ice milk. Walmart's own brand of ice cream tastes better and it's a lot cheaper. And some of Target's offerings are almost gourmet (chocolate peanut is addictive). Not sure what Blue Bell did after the recall but they're obviously cutting corners to make up for the enormous loss that situation must have created. Won't be buying again anytime soon.
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
2 comments
Guest

Totally agree and was thinking the same thing. I used to love their vanilla but it is *** now.

Guest

I agree, what the heck was making bluebell taste so good? Whatever it was is gone now.

Like the reviewer said, this tastes like cheap ice milk. This is terrible. I had some from a pint the other day and thought it had been thawed and refrozen. That kind of bad.

Bought the half gallon yesterday and it was just as bad.

I am sooooooo disappointed. At this rate, bluebell as a company has a shelf life of 6 months I say and then they're gone forever.

View more comments (1)
Anonymous
map-marker Brandon, Mississippi

Blue Bell Creameries Cookies And Cream Ice Cream Review

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
It taste horrible compared to what it taste like now
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Ottawa, Ontario

Blue Bell Creameries Ice Cream Review

Blue bell what have you changed in your ice cream.lts nothing like it was before all the problems.It use to be the best you could buy.I predict if you dont go back to your old recipe you wont be in the ice cream business much longer.Blue bunnie, Brookshiers and especially home made have you beat bad.
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Phoenix, Arizona

Blue Bell The Great Divide Ice Cream Review

I recently moved 2 Arizona after falling in love with this place. But the one thing I REALLY fell in love with, was the Southern Hospitality icecream
View full review
Reason of review:
Good quality
Anonymous
map-marker Shreveport, Louisiana

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

Ice cream does not have. Home made Flavor.taste medicated
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Houston, Texas

Blue Bell Ice Cream Review

Blue Bell Creameries - Simple Review #1452288015
Blue Bell Creameries - Simple Review #1452288015 - Image 2
Me and my husband got really sick after eating the peppermint ice cream attached is the number marking the container please check into this!
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Lindsay, Oklahoma

None of the ice cream taste the same and it looks super strange when coming out of the freezer

I have loved Blue Bell for years, I was pumped when it came back to the store. After buying several gallons multiple times and spending the $7 it cost, we are only getting one use out of it and having to throw it away.

It gets this super strange look to it, like it has melted and then refroze. It is really icy and the taste is totally different.

I'm so sad that the taste has changed so much and the fact that I can't even eat but one serving from it. Hopefully Bluebell will change this issue and get it all fixed.

View full review
Pros:
  • Because it is the only good ice cream around
Cons:
  • Comeback flavors are icy and low quality
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Tamesha Msw

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Baytown, Texas

Blue Bell Creameries Ice Cream Review

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Blue Bell is not the same!! Ice has almost no favor and I've purchased 7 gallons of Butter Pecan since back in stores and each time the pecan were stale!! Totally sucks! I should be reimbursed!
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Luisantonio Cfx
map-marker Abilene, Texas

Other Product Review

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Dear Blue Bell, I glad your back. Please explain why it took so long to get back in the market? . Ed Lee Kinder
View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Antioch, Tennessee

Not the same

Just bought my favorite Blue Bell flavor of ice cream after having not had it since it was pulled from the store shelves. I'm sooo disappointed, it's just not the same.

Not creamy like it used to be. Thought they could make a comeback, but after definitely tasting a difference and not a good one...not so sure they're going to make it. What happened Blue Bell?

I'd have thought you'd want to come back on top. I guess I'll just have to start looking for new creamier brand..sooo disappointed!

View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality

Preferred solution: I don't care about a refund or want anything for free...I just want my old Blue Bell back..that's all!

3 comments
Leyton Lhz

You are so right. Blue Bell is no longer quality ice cream!

Kirkland (Costco) vanilla ice cream is better than Blue Bell is now. Blue Bell was like a gelato ice cream (sticky) before you changed the recipe. It was creamy and was not flavored with artificial flavors and preservatives. Now it has corn syrup.

What gives? We want the original recipes back, until then I will buy a different brand.

Guest

I agree. The homemade vanilla no longer has that custardy taste that made it special.

I've sadly gone back to HEB 1905 vanilla which is code but the old Bluebell. Very sad sigh

Laina Tnu
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1113063

Just bought Blue Bell ice cream in Las Vegas.The old fashion vanilla has lost that special custard taste. Very disappointed. I want pay the extra cost for Blue Bell.

View more comments (2)
Anonymous
map-marker Port Saint Lucie, Florida

Natural Vanilla Bean

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Bought two gallons of natural vanilla bean at Walmart in Port Saint Lucie, Florida. I`am still looking for the bean, the flavor of vanilla and taste not the same as before the plants closing down.The color alone was whiter than my under-wear. Loved Blue Bell ice cream all my life, but not this time around. Please check quality control and get back to the public, with a reasonable explanation. Hopefully the rush back to market, will not be your downfall.
View full review
Cons:
  • No home made flavor
  • Comeback flavors are icy and low quality
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Marksville, Louisiana

Homemade Vanilla Disappointment

We have been long time fans of Blue Bell Ice Cream and couldn't wait to visit family in the south to get some of our favorite homemade vanilla. What a disappointment!!! I knew with the first *** that it was not the original that set it miles apart from other ice creams. In fact, we have been purchasing a much cheaper store brand of low fat homemade vanilla that is superior to this. I am so sorry that we won't be buying any more unless that great homemade vanilla taste makes a return. So sad!!
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Bay Minette, Alabama

Blue Bell Creameries Ice Cream Review

The home made vanilla I had does not taste like it did before the recall. It is less sweet and definitely does not taste like it did.....bring it back!!!!!
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
Anonymous
map-marker Singer, Louisiana

Blue Bell Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Review

The cookie dough is different now. Smaller pieces and doesn't taste good. Please change it back!
View full review
Reason of review:
Not as described/ advertised
Anonymous
map-marker Conroe, Texas

Blue Bell Creameries - Blue Bell Cookies And Cream Review from Conroe, Texas

Blue Bell Creameries - Blue Bell Cookies And Cream Review from Conroe, Texas
Blue Bell Creameries - Blue Bell Cookies And Cream Review from Conroe, Texas - Image 2
Blue Bell Creameries - Blue Bell Cookies And Cream Review from Conroe, Texas - Image 3
Blue Bell Creameries - Blue Bell Cookies And Cream Review from Conroe, Texas - Image 4
Found a strange chalky, bitter substance in the icecream. Isn't melting and not sure what it is. Thought it was a cookie chunk before biting into it! Placed substance into zip-lock bag.
View full review
Reason of review:
Bad quality
  • 1
  • ...
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • ...
  • 22