Manufacturer: Blue Bell Creameries Category: Ice Cream Clear all filters (11 of 11 reviews match)
filters
manufacturer:
seller:
Show
state:
Show
city:
Show
category:
I have no idea what changed in the recipe but the homemade vanilla is not the same. I used to buy up to 1-2 1/2 gallons a week over $12.00 a week). Now it takes my family and I up to 2 weeks to finish a 1/2 gallon. The taste is not even close to what is was before. I...
Read more
Anonymous
phoenix17

I tried this for the first time tonight and it was AWFUL!! So icy and grainy, not creamy at all. Ice cream is supposed to be CREAMY...what is wrong with this? This was my fir...

Anonymous
Anonymous

What has happened to peach and cantaloupe ice cream? It has always been the best.

Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
#1025590
Reply to reviews
Looks like the recipe for the Homemade Vanilla has lost the sweetened condensed milk flavor and is now sweeter which I don't care for, looks like you are loosing me as a customer, and I buy lots of this stuff. Please let me know when you change it back. Your web site...
Read more
Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
#1017145
Reply to reviews
It is just not the same ice cream! I particularly liked the Homemade Vanilla, Strawberries and homemade vanilla, and when available Peaches and homemade vanilla. The old recipe had whole, real, strawberries that were great! The new tastes exactly like strawberry jam...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

My wife and I felt like the taste of the homemade flavor changed as well. We didn't remember there being high fructose corn syrup and regular corn syrup in the ingredients lis...

Anonymous
RonfromTexas

Blue Bell homemade vanilla doesn't taste the same to me and several of my friends as it did before the 'meltdown' over listeria. 2-16-17.

2.0
Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
#991077
Reply to reviews
I've been willing to take the risk of whatever contaminated just to have my strawberries and homemade vanilla again. Finally my wife found strawberry at Walmart last month. I knew she had bought the wrong flavor so I gave them the benefit of the doubt when it tasted...
Read more
Anonymous
Doug

I agree. Blue Bell has ruined this once delicious, creamy ice cream.

Anonymous
Anonymous

I ate a different flavor today. Consumed about 1/2 a cup and had to quit eating it bc it tastes strange. Began to feel sick later and threw up along with severe abdominal pain...

2.0
Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
#931763
Reply to reviews
I've bought a half gallon of Homemade Vanilla and Strawberries & Homemade Vanilla and they are not the same quality. Their ice cream used to be the best and tasted just like home churned, but now it taste like all the cheap ice cream. Definitely not worth the money....
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

Eating some now. Was so excited about the return. No homade flavor. Not the same.

Anonymous
Anonymous

I'm glad I'm not the only one. It tastes really cheap!!!!

1.9
Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
#923385
Reply to reviews
Normally on Sunday evenings after dinner we watch television and eat bluebell homemade vanilla ice cream and cake. Well on 6/12/2016, it was time for ice cream. My mom did not want any so I had some myself. About 15 minutes after eating the ice cream. I started to get...
Read more
2.3
Product
Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream
I didn't like
  • Ice cream made e sick
  • Quality of ice cream
#865176
Reply to reviews

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

#1029748
1.0
Why in the world would Bluebell mess with the most perfect vanilla ice cream recipe ever created? So sad that they have ruined this Texas tradition. It is nothing but a memory now and I will be looking for a difference company to satisfy my homemade vanilla craving.
Comment
Show

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

#923338
Not what it used to be. It is not as creamy tasting. I have a rare smelling disorder. This was only ice cream for taste. Now it is more like the other brands. Soooo sad. We never battled over price. Homemade vanilla and strawberries was in strawberry ice cream instead, not vanilla. Lousy. Not what my brain was wanting.
Comment
Show

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

#868951
We bought a point of vanilla homemade icecream and it made us so sick. The icecream tasted very different. We usually buy blue Bell twice a month but this batch was bad.
Comment
Show

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

#855060
Ice cream does not have. Home made Flavor.taste medicated
Comment
Show

Blue Bell Creameries Homemade Ice Cream Review

#846883
2.4
A long time customer but very disappointed with whatever you did to the product. It's not as creamy and for some reason, it starts melting very rapidly. It's not hot here yet, so that's not the issue. I don't plan on buying any more. Maybe chage the name to just vanilla because it does not have the home made taste.
Comment
Show